Top 10 Healthy Toast Toppings for Babies and Toddlers

*This post may contain affiliate links, see our disclosure policy for details.

Toast with an amazing spread is a great go-to food when you’re busy and need a quick snack or meal. All you have to do is toast some bread… spread a topping… and BAM! You’ve got a delicious snack that was made in less than 2 minutes. 

I think it’s safe to say that we all love toast… and guess what? So do babies! It’s the easiest baby breakfast idea ever! 

But sometimes thinking of new ideas for what to put on toast to keep it varied, nutritious and safer for your baby to eat is hard! In this blog post, I’m going to show you my top 10 nutritious toppings for your baby’s toast – all easy and dietitian approved!

ten healthy toast toppings for babies and toddlers

Toast is an excellent food for both babies and toddlers. For babies, it can easily be cut into skinny strips that are the perfect finger food for them to hold in their fist using their palmar grasp. 

It’s also the perfect vehicle for nutritious spreads that are otherwise hard for babies to pick up and eat when doing baby led weaning. Although you can technically eat cream cheese or hummus off a spoon – it’s so much more delicious when you have it spread on something with a little more texture! 

But besides it tasting better with a spread, there’s actual nutritional and safety reasons for why we would want to add a healthy toast topping when serving toast to babies and toddlers. 

Let’s get into the benefits of toast toppings, when you can introduce bread to your baby, and more. Then I’ll share with you my top 10 toast toppings for babies and toddlers!

The benefits of healthy toast toppings for babies and toddlers

There are so many benefits to adding healthy toast toppings to your baby or toddler’s menu. Let’s take a look!

Benefits of healthy toast toppings for babies and toddlers

Benefit #1: An easy way to add variety and expand taste buds

Let’s talk about babies first. Adding toppings to toast is an awesome way to introduce new foods, flavors, and textures to babies to develop their taste buds and help them become adventurous little eaters. 

Did you know that the time between the ages of 6-12 months is a critical period for promoting adventurous eating and avoiding the pitfalls of picky eating? Babies are much more likely to accept new foods and flavors during this period of time, so offering a variety of different toast toppings on your baby’s toast is an easy way to expand their taste buds and “taste train” them, if you will, without adding a whole bunch of cooking for you! 

With toddlers, it’s important to make sure that food is showing up in different ways each time we serve it to them (or at least, whenever that’s possible). That’s because toddlers are known to get stuck in food ruts, wanting the same food over and over again, and losing their cool every time something looks different or new. 

In order to help overcome this, we keep even simple foods like toast new and different by simply offering different spreads on top. So, instead of the same ol’ peanut butter and/or strawberry jam, maybe you switch it up to almond butter or blueberry jam – or a different spread altogether! 

This is a classic strategy that can be built on to really help expand your picky eater’s diet – all found inside my Feeding Toddlers online course. Check it out if you’re looking to make changes with how your toddler eats to prevent/overcome picky eating.

Benefit #2: Toast is a great vehicle for hard to eat foods

Another benefit of using toast toppings is that it’s a great way for your baby to eat foods that they otherwise might not be able to eat easily. For example – flaked tuna or beans are hard for babies to pick up with their fingers until they develop their pincer grasp. Nut butters form into big globs and are too thick on a spoon, which poses a choking hazard. Avocado can be slippery and hard to make it into your baby’s mouth. 

You get the point. 

Mashing hard-to-pick-up foods and spreading them on toast is an easy way to include foods in your baby’s diet that provide specific nutrients they need.

Benefit #3: Toppings make toast easier and safer for babies to eat

Dry toast without any toppings poses an increased risk for choking for both babies and toddlers. It’s very hard to chew and requires a lot of saliva production to moisten it enough so that it can be safely swallowed. Toppings will ensure the toast is moist so that it’s easier and safer for babies to eat and swallow! For a full list of choking hazards for babies and toddlers, click here.

Benefit #4: Toast toppings create balanced meals and snacks

Here’s another really good reason why toast toppings are so great. On its own, toast provides a great source of carbohydrates and, depending on the type of bread, contains some fiber as well! But, carbohydrates and fiber aren’t enough to make up a balanced meal. Instead, I recommend always adding a topping that follows my FFP™ Rule for balanced meals (read about it in this blog).

This is an easy formula for building meals and snacks that I always recommend to clients. FFP™ simply stands for Fat, Fiber, and Protein. The rule is that every meal should include a good source of each of these three major nutrients, while snacks should include at least two out of the three nutrients. 

So, since toast is part of the fiber category, you need to add toppings from the protein and/or fat category to create a more balanced plate for your baby or toddler. This will provide more calories, and the right mix of nutrients, which will better balance their blood sugars and will keep them full until their next meal or snack. 

Keep reading for my ultimate list of 10 healthy toast toppings to create balanced snacks and meals for your baby or toddler!

When can I introduce toast to my baby?

Now, you may be wondering if and when toast is a safe food to introduce to your baby. Toast can be introduced at around 6 months of age, or at the time when it’s safe to introduce solids to your baby. The exact age for this will depend on if your baby is showing all the developmental signs of readiness for starting solid foods.

toast for babies

Toast is actually one of the top 8 foods I recommend for starting your baby on solids, and is a great first food! Although, it’s important to note that while toast is safe for babies to eat at 6 months, fresh or untoasted bread isn’t, and is considered a choking hazard. But don’t worry, I’ll be explaining that more and will go over how to prepare toast safely for your little one, below.

What to look for when choosing a bread for your baby or toddler

With so many options for bread these days, it can be time consuming to read all the labels and figure out which bread is best for your baby.

A couple of key things to note are: 

  • Make sure that there are no large seeds, like pumpkin or sunflower seeds, in the bread as they’re choking hazards for babies and young toddlers. 
  • Ensure that the bread is free of honey as an ingredient for babies under 1 year old.

For my other recommendations on what to check for on the nutrition label, see my blog post all about bread for babies. I also provide you with my top brand recommendations to help narrow down your search while shopping!

Fresh bread vs. toast

For babies, we always choose toast! Remember, fresh, soft bread is considered to be a choking hazard until approximately 18 months of age, depending on your child’s chewing skills. This is because it tends to gum up and form balls in babies’ mouths, which could then get lodged in the airway. But, when prepared properly, the risk is greatly reduced.

To help prevent choking, you can lightly toast the bread to make it slightly more firm. This also makes it easier for your baby to hold, as it won’t be too soft, and therefore won’t fall apart as easily.

healthy toast toppings for toddlers

I always get a ton of questions asking me how long to toast the bread for, but honestly, this varies and depends on the type of bread you’re using, and what toaster you have! Generally, you want to toast the bread until it becomes a light brown color and can break apart easily. If it’s toasted for too long, it may become too crunchy and dry. 

Remember, spreading a topping on toast can help make sure it’s not too dry for your baby! If you still don’t feel confident knowing exactly how long to toast the bread for, I’ve got you covered! Check out the demo below on what texture you should look for when toasting bread so that it’s safe for your baby to eat.

How to cut toast for my 6 - 12 month old baby

Once the bread is lightly toasted, the next step is to cut it into narrow and long strips, or finger shapes, that make it easier for your baby to hold. When offering toast in long strips, you can let your little one dip the toast strips into foods like applesauce or yogurt. This is another great way to use toast as a vehicle for added nutrition and texture exposure, plus it allows your baby to practice a dipping motion, which helps develop their motor skills.

When your baby or toddler has developed their pincer grasp (typically this happens around 9 months old), you can cut toast into 1” bite-sized pieces that your child can pick up with their forefinger and thumb.

How to cut toast for toddlers 1+ years old

By 12 months of age, your toddler has had lots of opportunities eating a variety of foods and developing skills, and is now likely able to eat what you’re eating, with only a few modifications. 

When serving bread safely to your toddler, you’ll still want to lightly toast the bread (until at least 18 months of age), and then you can spread your topping on it. When cutting toast for your 1+ year old, you can still cut toast into small 1” bite size pieces that they can pick up with their pincer grasp, or practice eating using an age appropriate fork

You can also cut up their toast into quarters, and then once they’re 18 months and up, they’ll probably be ready to try eating toast cut in half. But, you may need to be conscious about reminding them to take small bites, and not to over-stuff their mouth. I’ve got some good tips on encouraging this in a guest blog written by a Speech Language Pathologist, here.

Now, have you ever tried cutting your toddler’s food into fun shapes? A bonus tip to help your toddler accept these new flavor combinations is to use the power of novelty to make toast fun and enticing for your little one to try! 

Vegetable cutters and cookie cutters can be used to cut toast into different shapes, which can be a great way to help your toddler try new foods, flavors, and textures! Here’s a link to my US and Canadian Amazon Shops where I’ve included my favorite novelty tool products, including fun vegetable and cookie cutter shapes, as well as many other tools to help with picky eating at mealtime.

Food play with toast for toddlers

Remember, if you’re struggling with picky eating, or are looking to prevent picky eating in your toddler, check out my Feeding Toddlers online course for a step-by-step plan.

A note on allergens and toast toppings for babies

You may notice that some of the healthy toast toppings for babies and toddlers that I recommend below are considered highly allergenic foods. For example, dairy, peanuts, and tree nuts, like almonds. It’s recommended to introduce allergenic foods at around 4-6 months of age, or soon after starting your baby on solids, and toast toppings are a great way to do this! 

Since bread contains wheat and wheat is an allergen, toast is also considered to be a highly allergenic food. When introducing allergens to your baby, it’s very important to offer them one at a time. Don’t offer one of the top food allergens as a toast topping to your baby until wheat as an allergen has been ruled out first.

healthy toast toppings with top allergens for babies

I completely understand that introducing allergens can be stressful, but I don’t want you to worry. I have a blog post with ALL the information you need on introducing highly allergenic foods to your baby in a confident manner! 

And, if you want more information on how to safely start solids with your baby (whether with purées or finger foods) and healthily feed them up until 12 months of age, check out my Baby Led Feeding online course for an expert and research backed step-by-step plan.

Now let’s get to my favorite healthy toast toppings for babies and toddlers!

10 Healthy Toast Toppings for Maximum Nutrition

#1: Thinly spread nut and seed butters

nut or seed butter for added nutrition on toast

Nut and seed butters are great to add as a toast topping as they provide an excellent source of healthy fats for your little one! Some of my favorites are peanut, almond, hazelnut, pumpkin, and sunflower seed butter. Choose an all natural version (just the nut/seed, oil and maybe salt). Avoid overly processed ones with added sugar, canola oil or other ingredients. 

It’s important to note that nut and seed butters should be spread thinly on toast, as large amounts are sticky and can become a choking hazard.

And since wheat and nut butters are both highly allergenic foods, only serve this combination once you’ve ruled out at least one of these allergens already.

#2: Cottage, ricotta, or goat cheese

cheese or labneh on toast for a nutritious toddler snack

Dairy products are a great source of protein, fat, and calcium for your little one! Dairy is also a highly allergenic food, so ensure that there’s no allergy to wheat first before adding in a second allergen, such as dairy. 

Bonus Tip: Watch the sodium content in cheese if using it as a toast topping, as it tends to be a little high. If adding cottage cheese as a topping, you can dilute the cottage cheese in a little bit of plain yogurt so that there will be less salt per serving. 

I don’t want you to stress about this too much though, just be aware of it and try to offer other foods that are lower in sodium throughout the day, or the next day, to balance it. Read more about sodium for babies and why we don’t need to worry as much as you may think, here.

#3: Mashed avocado

avocado toast

I LOVE adding avocado as a toast topping as it’s rich in healthy fats which can promote proper growth and development for babies and toddlers! Avocados are also an excellent source of fiber, vitamin E, K, C, and many other nutrients to help your little one flourish.

#4: Hummus

hummus on toast for babies and toddlers

Hummus is another easy topping to spread on toast that offers a great calorie add-on and source of healthy fat! Hummus also comes in many different flavor combinations, such as roasted red pepper and roasted garlic, that will add variety to your baby’s or toddler’s meal. 

It’s important to note that hummus often contains tahini as an ingredient, which is made out of sesame seeds, a highly allergenic food. So, as with nut butters and dairy, make sure you’re certain that there’s no allergy to wheat first before offering hummus as a toast topping.

#5: Smashed berries or homemade jam

homemade jam for babies and toddlers on toast

Mashing fruit and adding it as a toast topping for your baby or toddler is a great way to add some sweetness to a meal or snack without any added sugars! And if you want to add a little extra boost of nutrition to the mashed fruit, try hemp, chia, or flax seeds sprinkled on top! And because these seeds are so small, they’re not considered a choking hazard

To learn more about the amazing benefits and nutritional power of these seeds for babies and toddlers, check out my podcast on superseeds with Tiny Sprouts!

Homemade jam is another great option for a toast topping, as store bought jam often contains a lot of sugar. If you’re looking for ideas, check out my 60 day baby led feeding meal plan that includes a delicious 3 ingredient chia seed jam recipe!

#6: Mashed beans, lentils or chickpeas

mashed beans on toast for babies

Beans and lentils are also a great toast topping as they’re rich in iron which helps your baby meet their iron requirements! Until babies master their pincer grasp, this is a really great way to include beans in the diet which might otherwise be too hard for them to pick up unless you cook them in some sort of burger. All you have to do is mash the beans or lentils with the back of a fork and then spread them on the toast! 

Canned beans, lentils, or chickpeas are perfectly fine for a quick and healthy option. Just aim to choose canned products stored in a BPA free liner and, if possible, choose low or no salt versions. If you do have a higher salt version, rinse the beans, lentils, or chickpeas under water once or twice to remove some of the excess salt – and voila! Perfect to serve up without having to cook anything. 

Bonus Tip: To increase iron absorption, you can add a source of vitamin C to the meal. I love squeezing a bit of lemon juice on top of the bean mixture, which also provides greater variety in flavor for your little one to try – a win-win!

#7: Mashed eggs mixed with Greek yogurt

egg with Greek yogurt as a healthy toast topping for babies

Mashed eggs mixed with Greek yogurt is a nutritious toast topping that’s a meal in and of itself! This combination is full of fat, calories, iron and protein that will keep your baby or toddler full for longer. The eggs can be boiled ahead of time, or you can fry or scramble an egg on the spot, mash a bit and mix into whole fat yogurt so it spreads a bit easier.

To increase variety and exposure to different flavors in your baby’s diet, try mixing this topping with different spices each time you make it. Dill is one of my favorites! 

You can also try mashed egg mixed with avocado, hummus, mayo or tomato sauce.

This toast topping includes 3 top allergens, including the toast, so make sure that at least two of the foods have been previously tested and ruled out as an allergen before offering this combination to your baby for the first time. 

Bonus Tip: Make sure that the egg is cooked really well so that there’s no runny yolk before serving to your baby, to reduce the risk of foodborne illnesses.

#8: Mashed banana with hemp seeds

mashed banana with hemp seeds on toast for babies and toddlers

This is a quick and nutritious toast topping to whip together for an easy meal or snack for your baby or toddler. Not only does the banana offer fiber, but also potassium and other important nutrients for your little one. 

And remember how we talked about my FFP™ Rule previously? Toast and banana provide lots of fiber, but to balance it out as a snack or meal, adding hemp seeds will provide protein and a healthy source of fat. This gives that extra boost of nutrition and keeps your baby, or toddler, full for longer! 

My favorite superseeds are these ones made specifically for kids by Tiny Sprouts. Make sure to get 10% off your order with the code MYLITTLEEATER.

toddler sprinkles of chia, flax, and hemp seeds

#9: Puréed liver

liver as a healthy toast topping for babies and toddlers

I know, not everyone’s idea of a tasty meal, but hear me out. Liver is one of the most nutritious foods to give to your baby, and adds a huge vitamin and mineral boost as a toast topping for your baby or toddler, including iron, vitamin B12, and zinc. 

It’s important to know that liver has very high levels of vitamin A. While this nutrient is important for developing the immune system, eyes, and skin of babies, in large quantities there can be a small risk of overloading on too much Vitamin A. For this reason, I don’t recommend serving liver to your baby more than once per week. 

If you’re unsure how to prepare and cook liver for your baby, I’ve got an easy 10 minute liver paté recipe in my 60 Day Baby Led Feeding Meal Plan!

#10: Fish mixed with mayonnaise

fish with mayonnaise as a healthy toast topping

Fish offers so many great benefits for your baby and toddler. It’s high in protein, iron, B12, vitamin D, calcium, and is often high in DHA, which is very important for proper brain growth and eye development. I recommend serving fish to your baby a couple times a week, especially fatty fish.

Canned salmon is one of the best options for a toast topping as you can buy it ready to serve, and salmon is one of the highest sources of DHA. When buying canned salmon, make sure to look for one that is in a BPA free can and is free of added salt. Next, mash the salmon, or break it apart into tiny pieces, and mix it with mayonnaise (or plain yogurt!) for an easy and nutritious toast topping. You can also add in spices for added variety and flavor for your baby or toddler. Some of my favorites for fish are dill, parsley, and mint.

Another great fish option to add as a toast topping is canned sardines. It’s low in mercury, high in DHA, protein and iron, and for the most part…babies LOVE it! Check out how to serve sardines in a jiffy to babies and toddlers below.

Different fish can expose babies to a variety of tastes, smells, and textures to broaden their list of accepted foods. Feel free to test out different types of fish on toast with your baby. Try some with mild flavors, like tilapia, and some with strong flavors, like tuna, and anything in-between! 

Have questions on the safest fish for your baby? Check out this blog post for everything you need to know!

Other great toast toppings for babies and toddlers

  • Full fat yogurt (regular or Greek)
  • Applesauce
  • Baby food pouches (super easy in a pinch!)
  • Butter or ghee (a great way to add fat and calories to a meal!)

When it comes to toast toppings for babies and toddlers, there’s SO many options, which is what makes this snack and meal idea so great. Adding toppings to toast provides a healthy, nutrition packed, and balanced meal for your baby or toddler (without being too time consuming), so you can give yourself a pat on the back for a job well done! 

Don’t worry if your little one doesn’t eat it all, or only eats the toppings. Just remember not to pressure them to eat the food, to keep role modeling eating behaviours for them, and to keep providing a variety of foods, flavors, and textures. All of these things will help to ensure that they are well on their way to becoming an adventurous little eater!

If you want a step-by-step guide on introducing solid foods to your baby following a baby led feeding approach, using either purées, whole foods, or both, check out my baby led feeding course

And if you’re looking to manage or prevent picky eating in your toddler, you need my feeding toddlers course

Join thousands of parents who have graduated from the courses with confidence, achieved peace of mind, and have happy and stress-free mealtimes with their baby or toddler.

Pin this to save for later when you need some inspiration!

the best 10 toast toppings for babies and toddlers

SHARE THIS POST

meet edwena

Registered pediatric dietitian, mom of two and lover of all things related to baby and toddler feeding!

freebies!

4 Ways to 
Overcome Your Fear of Gagging in BLW

4 Steps to Overcome Your Fear of Gagging

7 Day Toddler Meal Plan

mle podcast

Catch up on the latest podcast episode

scared to transition to finger foods?

Join the FREE

5 Day Texture Timeline™ Challenge

Get confident in how and when to move your baby from purees to finger foods to advance skill & prevent picky eating!